History or the false memory?
March 14th, 2010A couple of new books on the Crusades have come out, and they’re the basis of an article, Recuers, not Invaders in the WSJ today. It may be behind the pay wall, but the article starts:
The recorded past and the remembered past are seldom the same. Nowhere is this more evident than with the Crusades. The Crusades were a belated counter-offensive of Western Christians to come to the aid of Christians of the East in defending their lands against the further expansion of Islam and to free the holy city of Jerusalem from Muslim rule. In the year 600 most of the Middle East, from present-day Turkey to Iraq, including Egypt and the southern Mediterranean coast, was Christian, and its principal cities— including Alexandria, Antioch, Damascus and Jerusalem—were vibrant centers of Christian life and culture. Within a century the entire region came under Muslim rule. The Byzantine Empire, which had reached from the Strait of Gibraltar to the Persian frontier, was reduced to a Greek state in Asia Minor, Greece and the Balkans.
…
The story is told anew by Jonathan Phillips in “Holy Warriors” and by Thomas Asbridge in “The Crusades.” But there is more here than a historical account. Both books tell another, no less interesting, story as well: how the memory of the Crusades was formed in modern times.
And an image used in the article

In the image you see some sense of the hoard of the Crusaders. They flowed across Europe causing no end of dismay in Constantinople, but Christianity needed rescuing. It didn’t need the history of taking out Jewish populations, but they did establish “Frankish” kingdoms in Jerusalem and the Near East. Those kingdoms perservered for a few generations, very few, and Islam beat them back. The war is still on. Islam refuses to live in peace with the Christians or the Jews. Muslim attacks on Christians are noted frequently, but do we ever move out of our torpor? It’s much easier to believe the “religion of peace” sop that is contantly thrown our way. It’s misinformation, nothing more, nothing less. Martyrs are still dying for the faith. We yawn.
Earlier today I clipped this video. LONG time since Saturday Night Live hit a home run like this one!
Hope you had a happy “Pi Day” (you know 3/14)











